When we evaluate children's mathematical development, we often look at what they can do today: recognize numbers, perform calculations, memorize math facts, or complete exercises accurately.
But mathematics is more than getting the right answer. It is also about understanding quantities, recognizing relationships, and applying concepts to problems a child has never encountered before.
A 2025 longitudinal randomized controlled study published in Scientific Reports offers an intriguing perspective on this distinction.
Researchers Sarah Le Diagon, Jean-Baptiste Van der Henst, and Jérôme Prado followed children who had participated in an adapted Montessori preschool intervention in France. Five years later, when the children were in fifth grade, the researchers found something that had not been apparent at the end of kindergarten: children from the Montessori group performed significantly better in mathematical problem-solving than their peers in conventional preschool education.
Let's look at what the research tells us.
The study followed up on an earlier randomized intervention conducted in a public preschool in France.
Originally, children were randomly assigned to classrooms following either an adapted Montessori curriculum or the conventional French public preschool curriculum.
Five years after the intervention, researchers were able to assess 97 children in fifth grade:
Importantly, both groups had attended conventional public elementary schools from first through fifth grade.
Researchers assessed several areas of development, including reading fluency, mathematical problem-solving, arithmetic fluency, memory, and social skills.
Three findings stand out.
A significant advantage in math problem-solving.
Children from the Montessori group performed better than their peers, with an effect size of Cohen's d = 0.58.
No significant difference in arithmetic fluency.
The two groups performed similarly on calculation-based tasks.
An earlier reading advantage was no longer present.
The reading advantage observed at the end of kindergarten had faded by fifth grade.
The distinction is important. The research did not find that Montessori children performed better in every academic area. Rather, the most notable fifth-grade difference emerged specifically in mathematical problem-solving.
And this advantage had not been observed at the end of kindergarten.
Why is the distinction between mathematical problem-solving and arithmetic fluency so important?
Consider two children working with the same mathematical problem.
One child may be able to calculate 24 + 36 quickly because they have memorized an efficient procedure.
Another child may understand that 24 represents two tens and four units, and that 36 represents three tens and six units. They understand how quantities combine, how ten units can be exchanged for a ten, and why the answer is 60.
Both children may arrive at the correct answer.
But the second child is also developing an understanding of the mathematical relationships behind the calculation.
This conceptual understanding becomes increasingly important when children encounter unfamiliar problems, multiple steps, larger numbers, and more abstract mathematical ideas.
The distinction helps us interpret the study's findings.
The Montessori group showed an advantage in problem-solving, but not arithmetic fluency.
One possible interpretation is that the long-term benefit may be more closely related to understanding mathematical relationships than to performing calculations faster.
This does not mean procedural fluency is unimportant. Children need both conceptual understanding and the ability to calculate efficiently.
It means that measuring mathematical ability through calculation speed alone may overlook an important dimension of learning.
Mathematics is hierarchical.
Children build new knowledge upon concepts they have already understood. Counting supports addition. Understanding quantities supports place value. Place value supports more complex operations. These relationships become increasingly important as mathematical tasks grow more demanding.
The researchers discuss several possible explanations for the delayed math advantage.
Understanding the base-10 system
Montessori mathematics introduces children to units, tens, hundreds, and thousands through concrete representations.
Children do not simply memorize that ten units make a ten. They can physically experience the relationship by exchanging quantities.
Learning through concrete materials
Manipulative materials give children a way to represent mathematical concepts physically.
These experiences may help connect abstract numerical symbols with quantities children can see, touch, combine, and compare.
Building foundations for increasingly complex reasoning
Early mathematical concepts can become building blocks for later problem-solving.
As children encounter more challenging mathematics, the relationships they previously explored may provide useful foundations for understanding new problems.
These are plausible explanations, not mechanisms directly proven by the study. Further research is needed to establish precisely how early Montessori experiences contribute to later mathematical development.
Nevertheless, the findings invite us to look beyond immediate academic performance.
Sometimes the value of an early learning experience becomes clearer only when children are ready to use what they have learned in more complex ways.
To understand why these findings are relevant to Montessori education, it helps to look at how mathematical learning is organized in the Montessori classroom.
Montessori mathematics follows a carefully structured progression, moving from concrete experiences toward abstract understanding.
Introduction to numbers
Children begin by exploring quantities and their corresponding symbols.
Number rods, sandpaper numerals, spindle boxes, and cards and counters help children connect numerical symbols with actual quantities.
Basic operations and the decimal system
Materials such as golden beads, the stamp game, dot game, and bead frames allow children to explore the structure of the decimal system and experience addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division.
Counting and number relationships
Teen and ten boards, hundred boards, and skip-counting activities help children recognize numerical patterns and relationships.
Math facts and operations
Children gradually develop fluency and confidence through repeated experiences with addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division.
Fractions
Fraction skittles and fraction insets introduce children to parts of a whole and the relationships between fractional quantities.
The materials are not simply hands-on activities.
They are part of a structured educational progression designed to help children experience mathematical relationships before working with increasingly abstract representations.
The principle is simple: concrete before abstract, understanding before memorization, and experience before abstraction.
The Montessori Data Lens report also explores the relationship between kindergarten mathematical performance and fifth-grade outcomes.
The correlation visualization shows how early math problem-solving scores relate to later fifth-grade mathematics performance.
Both Montessori and conventional students demonstrate a positive relationship between early mathematical performance and later achievement.
This reminds us that early mathematical development matters in every educational environment.
However, the relationship between early and later performance should not be confused with the effect of the educational approach itself.
Correlation tells us that two measures are related. It does not, by itself, establish why that relationship exists or prove that one caused the other.
The randomized intervention and its longitudinal follow-up provide a stronger basis for comparing the educational groups.
Together, these findings encourage a broader perspective: we should consider both what children know early and how different educational experiences may influence the development of their mathematical abilities over time.
The research reveals an important challenge for early childhood education.
Some educational benefits may take years to become measurable.
But parents cannot make decisions five years from now.
They make decisions today.
They decide whether their child is progressing, whether they understand the school's approach, and whether they feel confident continuing Montessori education.
If the benefits of early Montessori experiences take years to become visible, how can parents recognize their value in the present?
The answer is to make the learning itself visible.
Our Montessori Parent Survey found that parents' number one challenge was a lack of understanding or clarity about their children's daily Montessori activities.
Parents may see their children working with golden beads without knowing that they are exploring the decimal system and place value.
They may see repeated activities without recognizing the purpose of repetition.
They may receive photographs of classroom experiences without understanding the developmental capabilities those experiences support.
The problem is not necessarily that children are not learning. It is that parents do not always have the information and context to recognize the learning taking place.
This becomes especially important when we consider the delayed findings in the research.
A child working with golden beads today may be developing an understanding of place value that supports increasingly complex mathematical reasoning in later years.
But parents cannot see that future outcome yet.
They need to understand the learning while it is happening.
Parents should not have to wait five years to understand what their children are learning today.
This is also why parent education needs to become part of the everyday school-family relationship, rather than something that happens only through occasional workshops, newsletters, or parent meetings.
When an explanation of a golden bead lesson arrives alongside a child's classroom update, parents can connect the material with the learning taking place.
When a Montessori lesson explanation is accompanied by a relevant video, a home activity, or a parenting tip, the classroom experience becomes an opportunity for the family to understand and support Montessori education.
Over time, these small moments can build a deeper understanding of the philosophy through the experience of watching Montessori unfold in their own child's life.
For schools, this creates an opportunity to strengthen parent understanding, confidence, engagement, and ultimately their commitment to the Montessori journey.
It is also the idea behind Montopia: making parent education an ongoing part of the child's learning updates, so that the educational purpose of each experience reaches families at the moment they are most interested.
Promising findings deserve careful interpretation.
The fifth-grade follow-up involved 97 children from a specific public-school context in France.
The original intervention used an adapted Montessori curriculum, rather than representing every aspect of a fully implemented Montessori program.
Furthermore, the fifth-grade math finding emerged from exploratory analyses. Although it was statistically significant and supported by Bayesian analysis, it requires further replication.
The study also found no significant differences in arithmetic fluency, memory, or sharing, and the earlier reading advantage was no longer present.
Therefore, we should not interpret the findings as proof that every Montessori program will produce the same outcomes or that Montessori is superior in every academic domain.
The most responsible conclusion is that this study provides promising evidence of a potential delayed benefit in mathematical problem-solving associated with an adapted Montessori early childhood intervention.
Larger studies and research across different populations and Montessori implementations will help us understand how broadly these findings apply.
The most interesting lesson from this research may be how we think about measuring early learning.
If we evaluate children's mathematics only by how quickly they calculate or how many problems they complete, we may overlook the conceptual foundations that support future learning.
Montessori mathematics invites us to look deeper.
It asks us to consider whether children understand quantities, recognize relationships, explore numerical structures, and gradually develop the ability to reason independently.
The 2025 longitudinal study offers an intriguing example of why this broader perspective matters: a mathematical problem-solving advantage that was not apparent at kindergarten emerged five years later.
For educators, it is a reminder that meaningful learning does not always produce immediate results.
For parents, it is a reminder that the activities they see today may be building capabilities that become more apparent in the years ahead.
And for the Montessori community, it is an invitation to continue researching, documenting, and communicating the value of the educational experiences we provide.
The real measure of early math education may not be how quickly a child calculates today, but how deeply that child understands mathematics tomorrow.
Le Diagon, S., Van der Henst, J.-B., & Prado, J. (2025). Early Montessori education shows delayed benefits for mathematical problem-solving in a 5-year longitudinal randomized controlled trial. Scientific Reports, 15, 43961.
Read the original research paper.
For us, Montessori Data Lens and Montopia are the same idea applied at different scales: making the invisible visible. Montessori Data Lens helps people understand a movement through research and data stories; Montopia helps families understand a child's learning through everyday classroom experiences.